SLA COMPARISON WORKSHEET

MSP Outsourcing SLA Scorecard

Compare up to three written SLAs against the same service, severity and required window. Enter each timer's target and measurement rule, mark the clause status and build a side-by-side checklist of the details still needed from each candidate.
Edited by Vasilii KaraUpdated Suggest a correction

Compare written SLA terms

Use the same service, severity and required window for up to three candidate documents. Open each timer to enter its target and measurement rule.

Start with saved services

Add up to three service names to an empty comparison. Copy commitments from each supplier's written SLA.

Choose and save services

Existing candidate details are kept. You can also enter names manually.

Imported service names do not confirm your selected product, coverage option or other requirements. Review the current saved requirements in a new tab and check each proposal against them.

Keep this comparison for later

Save a worksheet file to restore your service requirements, clause choices and timer notes. The file includes drafts for all three candidates, even when fewer documents are selected. Keep it in storage you approve for those details.

Use the blank Word worksheet to note the proposed SLA terms.

Open each timer to enter its target and measurement rule from the proposed document. A row marked Written needs both fields to count as complete. Empty fields remain questions.

Candidate 1
Scope, severity, pauses, escalation and remedies
Acknowledgement

Define the start and stop separately. Define whether an automated acknowledgement counts.

Work start

Define the start and stop separately. Identify the actor and the first action that starts work.

Mitigation

Define the start and stop separately. Define the observable reduction in business impact.

Restore

Define the start and stop separately. State the service condition that counts as restored.

Resolution

Define the start and stop separately. Identify the acceptance owner and the closure criteria.

Candidate 2
Scope, severity, pauses, escalation and remedies
Acknowledgement

Define the start and stop separately. Define whether an automated acknowledgement counts.

Work start

Define the start and stop separately. Identify the actor and the first action that starts work.

Mitigation

Define the start and stop separately. Define the observable reduction in business impact.

Restore

Define the start and stop separately. State the service condition that counts as restored.

Resolution

Define the start and stop separately. Identify the acceptance owner and the closure criteria.

Add document details, then build the comparison.

Inputs stay in this tab. Save a worksheet file to keep these inputs for later, or copy and print your output. No provider quality rating is calculated.

Complete the blank Word or Markdown worksheet, using the same service, severity and window for every candidate.

If you have saved a shortlist, start with those service names. The action adds labels to empty candidates; enter each document reference, proposed window and commitment from the written SLA. Your required service, severity and window stay as entered.

The five SLA timers

Five independent start-and-stop definitionsGive each timer its own target, service window and pause rules.
  1. Acknowledgement

    Start

    Agreed intake event

    Stop

    Agreed acknowledgement returned

    Define whether an automated acknowledgement counts.

  2. Work start

    Start

    Agreed actionable-ticket event

    Stop

    Qualified investigation or action begins

    Identify the actor and the first action that starts work.

  3. Mitigation

    Start

    Agreed incident-start event

    Stop

    Impact reduced or a workaround in place

    Define the observable reduction in business impact.

  4. Restore

    Start

    Agreed incident-start event

    Stop

    Service usable at the specified level

    State the service condition that counts as restored.

  5. Resolution

    Start

    Agreed resolution-start event

    Stop

    Agreed resolution or closure criteria met

    Identify the acceptance owner and the closure criteria.

The connectors show definitions, not elapsed durations. Replace the example start events with the agreed service clauses.

Copy each proposed target with its units and calendar. Define the start, stop and permitted pauses so an acknowledgement, first action and service restore remain separate commitments.

Read the completeness counts

The tool checks ten criteria: scope, severity, five timer definitions, pause rules, escalation, and reporting/remedies/exit terms. The clause statuses describe your document review:

  • Written - the proposed document defines the criterion for the service you are comparing.
  • Partial - the answer needs clarification or a timer lacks its target or measurement definition.
  • Missing - the clause has not been supplied or checked.

A timer marked Written counts as Partial until both its target and measurement rule are entered. A complete document can still contain an unsuitable service commitment, so review the actual targets and responsibilities as well as the counts.

Compare the measurement before the number

Proposed wording What to clarify
Fast response The target, start event and action that stops the timer
Response within a stated interval Whether response means acknowledgement or useful work; elapsed or business time
Restore target with an approval hold Who authorizes a pause, how it is logged and what restarts the timer
Same target under different calendars Timezone, staffed hours, holidays and the authoritative ticket timestamps

The tool preserves the text you enter. It does not convert business hours to elapsed time or infer that differently written targets are equivalent. Use the SLA guide's calendar example to settle those definitions. When reviewing a supplier's delivery percentage, check the request counts and severity split behind it.

Turn gaps into proposal questions

Open each candidate's question list in the report. Add the applicable agreement version, clause reference and service window. Ask for missing definitions in the same RFP before comparing written quotes.

Then sample the proposed workflow in a NOC pilot or help desk pilot. Document completeness and observed delivery answer different parts of the buying decision.

Keep your comparison

Use Keep this comparison for later to save a worksheet file and reopen your inputs. It includes drafts for all three candidates, even if fewer are currently selected. Opening a file restores the fields for review; build a fresh comparison before interpreting its completeness counts.

Use a blank Word SLA worksheet or Markdown SLA worksheet to keep the proposed targets, measurement rules and unanswered questions.

Copy the report, download it as Markdown or print just the comparison. Inputs stay in this tab and are not uploaded or saved automatically. Keep confidential client details in your approved systems and retain the original proposals alongside your notes.